Two Mothers

Once, a long time ago, there lived a man who had two wives, but only the younger one had given birth to a son. To protect her son from the older jealous wife, the younger wife gave the boy to the older one to raise as her own.
All went well until the father of the child died, and the two wives began to fight as to who owned the house and who owned the boy who was to inherit everything. After much arguing, the issue was finally taken to the king. Wanting to solve it as quickly as possible, the king called in both women and the boy.
The king said to the two wives, “As with all things, the stronger will win. The one who can hold onto the boy shall hold him forever.” The king then had each woman take hold of one of the boy’s arms and told them to pull. Instantly, the boy cried out in pain and then found himself in a heap on the floor with the older wife.
“We have our proof who the true mother is,” said the king. “He will live with the younger wife.”
“But I pulled harder, “ protested the older wife.
“Yes,” said the king, “and you lost.”

QUESTION FOR YOU.
How did the king know who the boy’s real mother was?

THE ANSWER.
The contest was not one of STRENGTH. It was a contest of LOVE. The boy’s real mother could not bear to hurt him, and so she let go. She wanted him to be safe even if she could not be with him.

VOCABULARY
1. to give birth to v. (The younger one had given birth to a son.) [give/s, gave, given]
(a) to have (to bear) a baby
(b) to give a gift to a baby
(c) to become pregnant
For example: I gave birth to my son in l973.
YOUR TURN: Please write a sentence (in any tense) using this phrasal verb –
give birth to.
2.to raise v. (The older wife raised the boy as her own.) (raise/s, raised, raised)
(a) to shave (b) to eat rice (c) to bring up
TO RAISE (verb needs an object) [This is NOT TO RISE.]
Examples: raise the flag, raise the window, raise your rent, raise your pay (salary),
raise your hand, raise your children
YOUR TURN: Please write a sentence (in any tense) using RAISE with an object.
________________________________________________________________________
3. the issue n. (The issue was finally taken to the king.) [issue/s, issued, issued]
(a) a newspaper
(b) an important question that must be solved or is in dispute
(c) a suit in court
4.in a heap n. (The boy found himself in a heap on the floor.)
(a) in a big pile (b) on the top (c) next to her
5.to protest v. (The older wife protested.)
(a) to prepare (b) to sing a song (c) to argue

5. to bear v. (She could not bear to hurt him.)
(a) to endure; to be able to tolerate something
(b) to be rude
(c) to see the bears at the zoo
Example: I can’t bear people who lie.
YOUR TURN: Please write your own sentence using bear in any tense.

____________________________________________________________________

GRAMMAR
WHO as a question word and
WHO as a subject of a clause, used as a relative pronoun
1. WHO as a question word.
(Use am, is, are, was, or were in your short answer)
a. Who is there? [at the door] It’s Sally. _______________
b. Who is going to Chinatown after school? ______________
c. Who was your teacher last semester? ________________
d. Who was eating in class? _________________
YOUR TURN: Use the verb to be to ask a WHO question? And answer it with two words.
e. ________________________________________________________ ___________
CAN or WILL as a modal ((Use can or will in your short answer)
f. Who can drive? ___________
g. Who will be here tomorrow?
YOUR TURN: Use the modals can and will to ask a WHO question? And answer it with two words.
h. ___________________________________________________ ________________
i. ___________________________________________________ _______________
PRESENT TENSE VERBS (Use do or does in your short answer)
j. Who has a dictionary? _____________
k. Who plays the piano? _____________
l. Who walks to school? ______________
m. Who works? _____________
YOUR TURN: Use a present-tense verb to ask a WHO question? And answer it with two words. n. _____________________________________________________ __________




PAST TENSE (Use did in your short answer)
o. Who walked to school today? ______________
o. Who ate breakfast this morning? _____________
YOUR TURN: Use a past-tense verb to ask a WHO question? And answer it with two words. p. _________________________________________________________ ____________
PRESENT PERFECT (Use have or has in your short answer)
Who has been to Las Vegas? _________________
YOUR TURN: Use a present-perfect verb to ask a WHO question? And answer it with two words. q. ____________________________________________________ ____________
2. WHO as a subject (or subject complement) of a clause .
Circle the verbs of WHO. Are these questions? ____________
1. Once there lived a man who had two wives.
2. The two wives began to fight as to who owned the house
3. and who owned the boy who was to inherit everything.
4. The one who can hold onto the boy shall hold him forever.

What are the subjects and verbs in the following sentences?
5. We have our proof who the true mother is.
Ask the WHO question for #5. ______________________________________
6. How did the king know who the boy’s real mother was?
Ask the WHO question for #6. ________________________________________
The grammar to learn for these embedded WHO “questions” is this:
DON’T make a WHO question in the middle of a statement.
a. I know who she is.
b. I always forget who works and who doesn’t.
c. I am sure she is the one who was here yesterday.
(whom is an object)
d. I am sure she is the one whom I saw in Chinatown.
e. I don’t know whom to ask.



3. Comparatives

Adjective Comparative
hard harder than But I pulled harder
old older than The older jealous wife was raising the son.
young younger than The younger one gave birth to a son.
strong stronger than The stronger will win.
YOUR TURN: Please write a sentence using safer.
safe safer than _______________________________________

3. CONVERSATION
Work with a partner and answer the questions.
Then write your answers in complete sentences.
a. What did the younger wife give to the older wife?
_________________________________________________________________
b. Who pulled harder? ________________
b. Who was physically stronger? ________________
c. Do you think the real mother (the younger mother) did the right thing by giving up her son? Please say why. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
d. Do you think the king was a wise person or was there another way to find out who the real mother was? Explain, please.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

©sgati2009

The Sticks of Truth

A long time ago in India, judges traveled from village to village. One day a judge stopped at an inn to rest, but the innkeeper was very upset. That day, someone had stolen his daughter’s gold ring.
The judge told the innkeeper not to worry and had all the guests come together so that he could question them. Each person told the judge, “I’m not the thief.” Since the judge could not figure out who the thief was, he decided to use some magic. He told them he was going to use the “sticks of truth”.
He explained, “These magic sticks will catch the thief.” He then gave each guest a stick to keep under their beds during the night. “The stick belonging to the thief will grow two inches during the night. At breakfast, we will all compare sticks. The longest stick will be the thief’s.”
The next morning, the judge had all the guests come over to his table and hold their sticks up next to his to see if they had grown. Each person held up his stick; but one after the other, they all were the same. None had grown any longer.
Then suddenly the judge called out, “This is the thief! Her stick is shorter than all the rest.”
Once caught, the woman confessed and she returned the ring; but all the guests were confused about the sticks. The judge had said that the longest stick would be the thief’s. Instead, it had been the shortest.
QUESTION: Why?
ANSWER: Not one of the sticks was magical. The only one who was worried about being caught had cut off two inches of her stick during the night so that she could hide its growth. Since the sticks were not magical, her stick ended up being the short one.
VOCABULARY Choose one answer.
1. an inn n. (A judge stopped at an inn to rest.)
(a) a hotel providing overnight lodging for travelers
(b) a truck stop
(c) a café
2. an innkeeper n. (The innkeeper was very upset.)
(a) a café owner
(b) a truck driver
(c) the person who owns or manages a hotel/inn.
3. guests n. (All the guests came together.)
(a) volunteers
(b) family members
(c) a paying customer in a hotel or restaurant
4. magic n. (He decided to use some magic.)
(a) music
(b) good food
(c) any art that makes you think impossible things are possible
5. confessed v. (The woman confessed and returned the ring.)
(a) to admit, under pressure, something inconvenient or damaging to oneself
(b) to be confused
(c) to fight with your fist

GRAMMAR
1. The judge told the innkeeper not to worry.
Report what you tell someone NOT to do. Use NOT + an infinitive
Examples:
I told my son NOT to play in the street. I told him TO PLAY on the sidewalk.
He told me NOT to call after 10 p.m.
YOUR TURN:


2. She had cut off two inches of her stick during the night so that she could hide its growth.
All the guests came together so that he could question them.
SO THAT clause (group of words) to show a result
Examples:
YOUR TURN:
a. I’m studying English so that ________________________________________
b. He went to the bank so that _________________________________________
c. I’m going to practice driving so that __________________________________
d. _______________________________________________________________





3. KNOW, DON’T KNOW + who, what, where, when, why, how
a. Do you know where India is? Where is India?
I know where India is.
I don’t know where India is.

YOUR TURN
b. Do you know what time it is? What ______________________ ?
I know what time it is.
I don’t know what time it is.

c. Do you know how much this book is? How much __________________?
I know ___________________________
I don’t know __________________________

Ask me a question like the ones above.
d. Do you know where______________________________________ ?
Where ___________________________________ ?
Tell me I know where _______________________________________________
I don’t know where __________________________________________

4. END UP + _ing
a. Her stick ended up being the short one.
b. She didn’t want the low-paying job;
but because she needed the money, she ended up taking the job.
YOUR TURN
c. _________________________________________________________

5. adjectives comparatives superlatives
Write the sentence from the story that uses the comparative and the superlatives.
short
comparative: __________________________________________________
superlative: __________________________________________________

long
comparative: __________________________________________________
superlative: __________________________________________________

YOUR TURN
tall
comparative: __________________________________________________
superlative: __________________________________________________





6. WORRIED ABOUT + noun or + gerund (two-word verbs)
a. The only one who was worried about being caught was the woman.
b. I’m worried about my test.
c. She’s worried about taking a plane.
d. He’s worried about being late.
YOUR TURN:


7. VERBS Find all the present, past, future, and past perfect verbs

subjects present past future past perfect
a. judges 1. 1. traveled 1. 1.
2. 2. 2. 2.
3. 3. 3.
4. 4. 4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
CONVERSATION
a. What do you think should be the punishment for the thief?


b. Do you think it was fair for the judge to use this method to catch the thief?




sgati©2009